How to Price Your Car for Sale

Setting the right price to sell your car is both a science and an art. Let’s take a look at what tools you can use to determine the right price.

Setting the right price to sell your car is both a science and an art. While it’ll require you to do some homework upfront, it can help you sell your car faster and arm you with all the knowledge you need throughout the negotiation process.

We’re going to focus on setting the right price to sell your car in a private party transaction. Though of course there are other options to selling as well—one of the most common practices is trading the vehicle in at a dealership. A trade-in is definitely more convenient and will save you a lot more time and effort than selling it yourself, but it comes at a cost, which we’ve detailed in our other post, here.

Let’s take a look at the factors that affect car pricing, and what tools you can use to determine the right price.

Know the market demand

Is your car popular? Are there seasonal factors that can affect the type of vehicle you’re selling? For example, a convertible probably won’t be in high demand in the middle of winter. If gas prices are high, then you’ll be able to command a bit more for a fuel-efficient car that gets great mileage. A bigger SUV might be less desirable for people living in the city where parking is limited, but could be more suitable for suburban families that have kids and pets that they need to transport day to day. You know your city and neighborhood best, so factor that in as you’re selling.

Research local listings

Consider this your "competitive research". As a private party seller, Craigslist is one of the biggest marketplace for people buying and selling cars. Do a quick search for similar make model vehicles that are available on Craigslist and how they are priced, that way you can price your listing competitively to get more responses.

It would also be helpful to know how much similar vehicle would cost at a dealership as well. In general, buyers who are looking to buy private party are cost conscious shoppers trying to save a few bucks. So if you’re pricing your car above retail prices at a dealership, there would be no reason for someone to contact you about your car at all. Thanks for various car sites, you can easily check used car prices at from local dealership through services such as Truecar or Cargurus.

Leverage Online Pricing Tools

Kelley Blue Book

KBB is one of the most established and trust resource when it comes to providing an objective value for vehicles. The site is easy to use, just follow the prompts on each step to enter details about your vehicle. KBB will provide both a trade-in price at a dealership, and a private-party price for your vehicle based on its condition.

CarGurus

On Cargurus, you will need to enter the VIN number of your car, your location, and vehicle mileage to get a value estimate. One useful tip Cargurus provides is the fair market price of the vehicle, and how it compares to national and local listings. However Cargurus does not factor in the physical condition of your vehicle—so adjust accordingly based on your vehicle’s wear and tear.

ClearBook by Truecar

Part of Truecar.com’s pricing tool for used cars analyzes millions of used car listings and transactions to determine your potential trade-in value and expected selling price. It provides a helpful range to help you determine if your list price is higher or lower than market average.

NADA Guides

National Appraisal Guides’ website is a useful tool provided by one of the main publishers on new and used vehicle pricing and information. After entering your vehicle’s information, their pricing tool returns a range of estimates based on your vehicle’s condition (clean or rough), and retail vs trade-in price.

Know what your price floor is

Now that you’ve done your pricing research, you should have a good idea on how to price your car if you were to sell it yourself, or how much you’d get via a trade-in. If you decide to move forward with selling it on your own, understand that buyers will most likely try to negotiate. Set a floor for yourself throughout the process - know that an offer below trade-in value isn’t worth your time. If you’re looking to sell your car quickly, price it competitively against the market average so your ad is more attractive to buyers.

It helps to create an effective listing, too. We’ve learned through thousands of listings here on Instamotor that including nice photos and a detailed, honest description goes a long way. For more tips to sell your car faster, check out the ultimate guide for you to sell your used car.

Buying Tips

How To Tell If You Are Getting A Good Lease Deal On Your New Car
When is the Best Time to Sell Your Used Car?
What is a 0% Car Loan?
2017 Car Shopping Trend Report: How Prepared Are Consumers?
What are Dealer Fees & Which Ones are Negotiable?

Financing

What is a 0% Car Loan?
What a Fed Rate Increase Means for Your Auto Loan
How to Refinance Your Car Loan
How Much Down Payment Do You Need to Buy a Used Car?
3 Main Factors in Getting a Car Loan

The Instamotor Team

Not your typical used car salesman. Our team is here to provide honest and transparent advice about car buying and selling.